Middletown, NJ Cash Home Buyers

We Buy Houses for Cash - Sell Your House Fast in Middletown, NJ

Get a Fair Offer for your Old House, Rental, or Inherited Property from a Local Cash Home Buyer

Get your free cash offer

Tell us about your house. We'll call you with a no-obligation offer.

No obligation · No fees · No repairs needed

Prefer to talk? (732) 301-2920

Your local owner Will Scott Meet your local team

1,300+

Homes Bought & Restored

Since 2008

A trusted local buyer

7-Day

Closings available

A+

BBB Accredited

As featured in

How it Works

Request a Cash Offer

Give us a call at (732) 301-2920 or fill out the form above and tell us more about your Home.

We Meet & Evaluate Your Home

We'll meet up with you to visit your home in person. Don't worry about cleaning up beforehand!

We Give You a Cash Offer

We will make you a fast and fair offer. We close quickly with cash in just a few days and pay all closing costs.

Meet Your Local Cash Home Buyer

Will Scott

Hi, I'm Will Scott, owner of New Again Houses Monmouth County. For more than 20 years, I've built my career in construction and real estate, helping transform properties into beautiful, functional homes. Before joining New Again Houses, I renovated more than a dozen homes as a contractor for other real estate investors, giving me firsthand experience in every stage of the renovation process—from identifying potential to delivering quality craftsmanship. Monmouth County isn't just where I work—it's home. My wife Noelle and I were raised here, and today we are raising our three-year-old son in the community we love. Because I live here, I take pride in helping improve the neighborhoods that have meant so much to my family. I believe every home has a story. Sometimes that story needs a new chapter. My goal is to responsibly restore homes with quality workmanship, respect for the surrounding community, and an eye toward the families who will create the next generation of memories there. Whether you're looking to sell a property that needs repairs, inherited a home, or simply want a straightforward, honest buying experience, I'm committed to making the process simple, transparent, and fair. In our free time we enjoy the beaches, parks, music and downtowns that make our community such a great place to live.

Call (732) 301-2920

Why Sell Your Home for Cash?

When you say, "I need to sell my house fast," you mean fast! At New Again Houses®, we understand that the typical real estate process may not be ideal for everyone.

Downsizing

Financial Reasons

Moving

Substantial Repairs Needed

Tired of Being a Landlord

Inherited Property

Divorce

Foreclosure

Liens / Code Violations

Taxes

Vacant / Abandoned Property

Distressed / Outdated

See Why Homeowners Choose Us to Sell Their Home Fast

Lisa Baron
★★★★★

Will Scott purchased a house from my husband and me “as is.” He gave us a terrific offer. He was fair, he was easy to work with, he was trustworthy and he was a man of his word. Will is a realtor and a contractor, and he handled all house inspections on our behalf. It was a pleasure doing business with him.

Rachel Meade
★★★★★

New Again made the process of selling our family home as easy and painless as possible and gave us an extremely fair offer. They answered any and all questions we had and were all around just nice to work with. Thank you!

Matt Robinson
★★★★★

Had a great experience with these guys. Everything went exactly as presented in our first call, and they just made the process so easy. The offer was fair and I would definitely recommend.

Sell Your Inherited or Old House Fast for Cash in Middletown, NJ

Looking to sell your old house, rental, or inherited property in Middletown, NJ? New Again Houses is your answer. We buy homes for cash in New Jersey, renovate them, and create beautiful homes for families to enjoy for years to come. As local home buyers, we pride ourselves on making the home selling process easy and fast. We buy houses as-is, use cash for quick transactions, and waive contingencies like appraisals and inspections. Plus, you won’t need to pay agent fees, which typically amount to 5-6% of the sale price—and we can finalize everything in just 7 days. If you want to sell your outdated or inherited house quickly in Middletown, NJ, contact us today!

What you skip when you sell to us

No commissions or closing costs
No repairs, cleaning, or staging
No open houses or showings
No appraisals or bank delays
Close in as little as 7 days

Get My Cash Offer

Selling Your Home to New Again Houses®
vs
Working With a Real Estate Agent

	New Again Houses®	Traditional Real Estate Agent
Commission Fees	NONE	6% on average, paid by you.
Closing Costs	NONE	3% on average, paid by you.
Staging & Marketing	NONE	Yes, your real estate agent may require this to sell your home.
Number of Open Houses & Showings	NONE, just us!	Yes, many depending on your neighborhood or market.
Inspections	NONE, we do our own!	Yes, can yield additional costs associated with repairs.
Repairs & Cleanup	NONE, we buy as is!	Yes, can be substantial depending on the state of your home. Paid by you.
Appraisal Needed	NONE, we make you a cash offer!	Yes, required for the sale of your home.
Average Days on Market	NONE	Average 40 days.
Average Days to Close	Your choice! Get cash in as little as 7 days after accepting our offer!	30-60+ days after accepting buyer's offer.

Close on Your Schedule!

We can close at your convenience or work with you to find the best solution, and we'll pay all closing costs.

Get a Cash Offer →

Recent Blog Posts

Benefits of Selling a House for Cash | New Again Houses Read article → How to Sell an Old House That Needs Renovations | New Again Houses Read article → Foreclosure Timelines & Redemption Periods by State | New Again Houses Read article →

Sell Your House Fast in Middletown, NJ

Get a fast & fair offer for your home and close at your convenience.

Get a Cash Offer

Frequently Asked Questions About Selling Your Home for Cash in Middletown, NJ

What areas of Middletown do you buy houses in?

All of Middletown Township, including Lincroft, Belford, Port Monmouth, Leonardo, Navesink, River Plaza and North Middletown, plus nearby Red Bank, Atlantic Highlands, Hazlet and the rest of Monmouth County. Will Scott was raised in Monmouth County and still lives here, so you're working with a local buyer, not a call center.

Will you buy my Middletown house as-is?

Yes. We buy houses in any condition, whether the kitchen hasn't been touched since the 1970s or the house needs a new roof, foundation work or a full renovation. You don't need to clean, repair or stage anything.

Are there any fees or commissions?

No. There are no agent commissions or hidden fees, and we cover the closing costs. The offer we agree on is what you receive at closing.

What happens after I accept your offer?

We open title with a local title company, handle the paperwork and set a closing date that works for you. You're welcome to have your own attorney review the contract. At closing you sign, and your funds are sent by wire transfer or cashier's check.

How fast can I sell my house in Middletown?

You can close in as little as 7 days. Because we pay cash, there's no appraisal or financing to wait on. If you need more time to move, you choose the closing date.

My house on the bayshore was damaged by Sandy or another flood. Can I still sell it?

Yes. Superstorm Sandy flooded much of Middletown's bayshore in 2012, including Port Monmouth, Belford and Leonardo, and some homes there still have damage or unfinished repairs. Since 2024, New Jersey has required sellers to disclose flood history. We buy flood-damaged homes as-is. Learn more: https://newagainhouses.com/blog/selling-homes-damaged-by-floods-fire-or-hurricanes

My house is older and has an oil tank. Will you buy it?

Yes. Much of Middletown was built in the 1950s and 1960s, and many of those homes were heated with oil. A buried tank, original wiring or old plumbing can make a mortgage buyer back out, but we buy as-is, so you don't need a tank sweep or upgrades before you sell. Learn more: https://newagainhouses.com/blog/how-to-sell-an-old-house-that-needs-renovations

I'm relocating for a new job. Can you close quickly?

Yes. Many Middletown homeowners commute to New York on NJ Transit or the ferry from Belford, and a new job can mean moving fast. We can close in as little as 7 days or on your timeline, and documents can be signed remotely if you've already moved. Learn more: https://newagainhouses.com/blog/how-to-sell-your-home-quickly-when-relocating

We've lived here for decades and want to downsize. Can you help?

Yes. Many of our Middletown sellers are longtime owners whose kids have moved out. You choose the closing date, and you can leave behind any furniture or belongings you don't want, so you don't have to empty a whole house before you move. Learn more: https://newagainhouses.com/blog/expert-tips-for-seniors-selling-their-homes

I inherited a house in Middletown. How does probate work?

Wills for Monmouth County residents are probated through the County Surrogate's office in Freehold. New Jersey requires a 10-day wait after the death before a will can be probated. Once the executor has Letters Testamentary, they can sell the house, and we're glad to work alongside your estate attorney. Learn more: https://newagainhouses.com/blog/sell-a-house-in-probate

I'm behind on my mortgage. Is it too late to sell?

Usually not. New Jersey foreclosures go through the courts and often take a year or more. You can sell any time before the sheriff's sale, and a fast cash sale can pay off the loan and protect your credit. Learn more: https://newagainhouses.com/blog/tips-for-avoiding-foreclosure-on-your-home

Why Choose New Again Houses to Sell Your Home?

There is no waiting, no contingencies, no banks, and no cleaning up the house. We buy houses as-is without the hassle so you can sell your house fast.

We buy houses in all shapes and forms. If you need to sell your house or you have inherited unwanted property, give us a call. We’ll get in touch with you as soon as possible to get more information about the home, and to set up a time to walk through it. Once we have evaluated the property in person, we can determine a fair offer and close quickly with cash.

We buy houses in Middletown and the surrounding areas and use talented local contractors to transform old houses into fantastic homes. Leave the question “How do I sell my house fast?” to us.

Servicing Middletown, NJ
Red Bank, NJ 07701

(732) 301-2920

We Buy Homes for Cash in Middletown, NJ & Surrounding Areas in Monmouth County

See all 15 service areas & ZIP codes

Asbury Park [07712]
Atlantic Highlands [07716]
Eatontown [07724]
Freehold [07728]
Hazlet [07730]
Lincroft [07738]
Long Branch [07740]
Matawan [07747]
Middletown [07748]
Neptune [07753]
Ocean Township [07712]
Oceanport [07757]
Red Bank [07701]
Tinton Falls [07724]
Wall Township [07719]